This mathematical fallacy is due to a simple assumption, that $ -1=\dfrac{-1}{1}=\dfrac{1}{-1}$ .

Proceeding with $ \dfrac{-1}{1}=\dfrac{1}{-1}$ and taking square-roots of both sides, we get:

$ \dfrac{\sqrt{-1}}{\sqrt{1}}=\dfrac{\sqrt{1}}{\sqrt{-1}}$

Now, as the Euler’s constant $ i= \sqrt{-1}$ and $ \sqrt{1}=1$ , we can have

$ \dfrac{i}{1}=\dfrac{1}{i} \ldots \{1 \}$

$ \Rightarrow i^2=1 \ldots \{2 \}$ .

This is complete contradiction to the fact that $ i^2=-1$ .

Again, as $ \dfrac{i}{1}=\dfrac{1}{i}$

or, $ i^2=1$

or, $ i^2+2=1+2$

or, $ -1+2=3$

$ 1=3 \ldots \{3 \}$ .

or, in general $ a=a+2, \ \forall a \in \mathbb{C} $

Again using equation $ \{1 \}$ and dividing both sides by 2, we get

$ \dfrac{i}{2}=\dfrac{1}{2i}$

$ \Rightarrow \dfrac{i}{2}+\dfrac{3}{2i}=\dfrac{1}{2i}+\dfrac{3}{2i}$

$ \Rightarrow i \dfrac{i}{2}+i \dfrac{3}{2i}=i \dfrac{1}{2i}+i \dfrac{3}{2i}$

$ \Rightarrow \dfrac{i^2}{2}+\dfrac{3}{2}=\dfrac{1}{2}+\dfrac{3}{2}$

$ \dfrac{-1}{2} +\dfrac{3}{2}=\dfrac{1}{2}+\dfrac{3}{2}$

$ 1=2 \ldots \{4 \}$

or, in general $ b=b+1, \ \forall b \in \mathbb{C} $

$ \Box$

Where is the error?

These fallacies were derived since we ignored the negative ‘Square-roots’ of 1 & -1. If we put $ \sqrt{1}=\pm 1$ and $ \sqrt{-1}=\pm i$ , then the results would have been different. Also note that $ \sqrt{-1}=\pm i$ but $ i= \sqrt{-1}=+\sqrt{-1}$ .

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

You May Also Like

Milnor wins 2011 Abel Prize

The Norwegian Academy of Science and Letters has decided to award the Abel Prize for 2011 to John Milnor, Institute for Mathematical Sciences, Stony Brook University, New York “for pioneering discoveries in topology, geometry and algebra”. The President of the Norwegian Academy of Science and Letters, Øyvind Østerud, announced the winner of this year’s Abel Prize at the Academy in…

The Mystery of the Missing Money – One Rupee

Puzzle Two women were selling marbles in the market place — one at three for a Rupee and other at two for a Rupee. One day both of then were obliged to return home when each had thirty marbles unsold. They put together the two lots of marbles and handing them over to a friend asked her to sell then…

What’s the question, if the answer is ‘No!’

Infinitely many answers questions are possible to the answer, “No”. So, our real task should be to find one of THOSE many, which seems to be a perfect one. A simple and the first ever logical approach of giving answers to a question is to derive answers from the question, that is, replace some words of the question with reasonable ones and…

Interesting Egyptian Fraction Problem

Here is an interesting mathematical puzzle alike problem involving the use of Egyptian fractions, whose solution sufficiently uses the basic algebra. Problem Let a, b, c, d and e be five non-zero complex numbers, and; $ a + b + c + d + e = -1$ … (i) $ a^2+b^2+c^2+d^2+e^2=15$ …(ii) $ \dfrac{1}{a} + \dfrac{1}{b} +\dfrac{1}{c} +\dfrac{1}{d} +\dfrac{1}{e}= -1$…

2014 – Most Googled Games in Indian States

The folks from coupon sharing website have created an interesting infographic featuring the list of games that were Googled most in different states of the country. The image below is the result of their statistical analysis of Google Search by Indian users for gaming specific keywords. It enlists 33 games from 33 Indian states & union territories. See which…

Abel Prize for 2014 to Yakov Sinai

Mathematical Physicist Yakov Gregory Sinai, (b. 21st September 1935, 78 years old) has been awarded the prestigious Abel Prize for 2014 by the Norwegian Academy of Science and Letters (NASL). The President of the NASL, Nils C. Stenseth, announced the winner of the 2014 Abel Prize at the Academy in Oslo on 26 March 2014. The Abel Prize recognizes contributions of…