Four friends Matt, James, Ian and Barry, who all knew each other from being members of the Automattic, called Automatticians, sat around a table that had a dish with 11 apples in it. The chat was intense, and they ended up eating all the apples. Everybody had at least one apple, and everyone know that fact, and each automattician knew the number of apples he ate. They didn’t know how many apples each of the others ate, though. They agreed to ask only questions that they didn’t know the answers to:

Matt asked: Did you eat more apples than I did, James?

James: I don’t know. Did you, Ian, eat more apples than I did?

Ian: I don’t know.

Barry: Aha!! I figured out..

So, Barry figured out how many apples each person ate. Can you do the same?

Matt: 1 Apple

James: 2 Apples

Ian: 3 Apples

Barry: 5 Apples

## The Logic

Matt could not have eaten 5 or more. James could not have eaten only one or he would have known that he hadn’t eaten more than Ian. Neither could he have eaten 5 or more. He could have eaten 2 or 3 or 4 apples. Ian figures this out, although he still doesn’t know if he ate more than James. This mean that Ian must have eaten 3 or 4 apples. Barry can only deduce the other amounts if he ate 5 apples. And the rest, in order to add up to 11 , must have eaten 1, 2 and 3.

Inspired from a childhood heard puzzle.

Related Articles Found on this Blog:

1. Wow! I’m impressed. I’m not at all mathematically inclined. I’m an artist and rather flakey when it comes to numbers.

2. Interesting! There may be more than one answer but the nearest probability is this one.

1. The first worthy comment on this topic. Actually the point, I assumed, that one will ask a question, whose answer he doesn’t know, makes the logic and provides the answer. Other answers might be possible- but As I said, it is inspired by a childhood heard puzzle, I thought not to make more changes than original. Thanks for your comment.

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

## On World Math Day – Do A Simple Self-Test to Identify a Creative Mathematician in You

There are many mathematicians, chemists, musicians, painters & biologists among us. But they are unaware of their qualities. Only some small suggestive strokes are needed for them. Unless one tells them, they will not know how great they are. Here is a small self test. Do you enjoy music, drums and dance? Do you enjoy looking at the flowers, carpets,…

## Light the bulb: An everyday logic puzzle

You are inside a room and there are exactly three electric bulbs outside of the room. The three bulbs have their corresponding switches (exactly three) inside the room. You can turn the switches on and off and leave them in any position. How would you identify which switch corresponds to which electric bulb, if you are allowed to go outside…

## Test your counting skills with Branifyd game for Android

Without basic operations of counting, like Addition, Subtraction, Multiplication and Division, it is not possible to imagine math problems. Counting is the base of human life. A student, whether he’s a math major or not, must be good at counting numbers.  The counting ability builds from experience and is definitely a time taking process.   Larger you have given time…

## Perseids : Long Story Short

What are perseids? Perseids are the regular and most predictable meteor shower which appear regularly every year. They are associated with Swift Tuttle comet and appear to rise from the radiant in the constellation Perseus. Swift Tuttle comet, formerly known as 109P, travels toward Earth’s part of solar system every 133 years leaving traces of perseids. It was last seen…

## Free Online Algebra and Topology Books

This is a brief list of free e-books on Algebra, Topology and Related Mathematics. I hope it will be very helpful to all students and teachers searching for high quality content. If any link is broken, please email me at gaurav(at)gauravtiwari.org. Abstract Algebra OnLine by Prof. Beachy This site contains many of the definitions and theorems from the area of…

## D’ ALEMBERT’s Test of Convergence of Series

Statement A series $\sum {u_n}$ of positive terms is convergent if from and after some fixed term $\dfrac {u_{n+1}} {u_n} < r < {1}$ , where r is a fixed number. The series is divergent if $\dfrac{u_{n+1}} {u_n} > 1$ from and after some fixed term. D’ Alembert’s Test is also known as the ratio test…