This is a puzzle which I told to my classmates during a talk, a few days before. I did not represent it as a puzzle, instead of a talk suggesting the importance of Math in general life. This is partially solved for me and I hope you will run your brain-horse to help me solve it completely. If you didn’t notice, this puzzle is not a part of A Trip To Mathematics series. Puzzle which I discussed in the talk was something like this:
I have done many proofreads of this puzzle and found it valid. Your comments, your ideas and suggestions might help me working more rigorously on this puzzle. This puzzle is neither too hard nor too easy. I will be updating this post frequently as my work on this puzzle is directed towards a correct way.
This is a famous problem of intermediate analysis, also known as ‘Archimedes’ Cattle Problem Puzzle’, sent by Archimedes to Eratosthenes as a challenge to Alexandrian scholars. In it one is required to find the number of bulls and cows of each of four colors, the eight unknown quantities being connected by nine conditions. These conditions ultimately form a Pell equation which solution is necessary in case of finding the answer of the puzzle.
- Longhorn Cows in the Southwestern Sun, By T.Paden
The Greek puzzle is stated below with a little deviation. I have just tried to make the language simpler than the original, hope you’ll be able to grasp the puzzle easily.
O Stranger! If you are intelligent and wise, find the number of cattle of the Sun, who once upon a time grazed on the fields of an Island, divided into four groups (herds) of different colors, one white, another a black, a third yellow and the last dappled color.In each herd were bulls, mighty in number according to these proportions:
- White bulls were equal to a half and a third of the black together with the whole of the yellow.
- The black bulls were equal to the fourth part of the dappled and a fifth, together with, once more, the whole of the yellow.
- The dappled bulls, were equal to a sixth part of the white and a seventh, together with all of the yellow.
So, these were the proportions of bulls, now the
proportions of the cows were as following:
- White cows were equal to the third part and a fourth of the whole herd of the black.
- Black cows were equal to the fourth part once more of the
dappled and with it a fifth part, when all cattle, including the bulls, went to pasture together. Now the dappled in four parts were equal in number to a fifth part and a sixth of the yellow herd.
- Yellow cows were in number equal to a sixth part and a seventh of the white herd.
Keeping above conditions in focus, find the number of cattle of the Sun, giving separately the number of well-fed bulls and again the number of females according to each color.
But come, this solution is not complete unless you understand all these conditions regarding the cattle of the Sun:
- When the white bulls mingled their number with the black, they stood firm, equal in depth and breadth. Number of bulls in a row were equal to the number of columns.
- When the yellow and the dappled bulls were gathered into one herd they stood in such a manner that
their number, beginning from one, grew slowly greater till it completed a triangular figure,
there being no bulls of other colors in their midst nor none
of them lacking.
Find the number of cows and bulls of each color separately.
[And if you're not serious about the test ...then read the whole post to know what the stupid author was trying to tell you. ]
STATEMENT: If the question you answered before you answered the question you answered after you answered the question you answered before you answered this one, was harder than the question you answered after you answered the question you answered before you answered this one, was the question you answered before you answered this one harder than this one? YES or NO? (more…)
This is a popular Chinese problem, on Linear, which in wording seems as a puzzle or riddle. However, when used algebraic notations, it looks obvious. The problems states :
|If a cock is worth 5 coins, a hen 3 coins, and three chickens together 1 coin, how many cocks, hens and chickens, totaling 100 in number, can be bought for 100 coins?|
This puzzle in terms of algebraic equations can be written as and
where being the number of cocks, hens and chicks respectively.
We find that there are two equations with three unknown quantities. So eliminating one of the unknowns, by putting from second equation into first one such that
Which is a linear Diophantine equation (with only two unknown quantities).
The equation has the general solution [links to ] and , so that where is an arbitrary integer.
Now, since are the number of creatures, hence and thus , and which imply that . And because t must have integer values, we have . Which gives the following three solutions:
|Values of||No. Of cocks ( )||No. Of hens ()||No. Of chicks ()|
So there are the three ways to chose the number of cocks, hens and chicken totaling 100 to buy for 100 coins.
Elementary Number Theory
David M. Burton, 2006
Wikipedia article on Diophantine Equations
Robert Said: I am now married and have three children.
Thomas Said: That’s great! How old they are?
Robert: Thomas! Guess it yourself with some clues provided by me. The product of the ages of my children is 36.
Thomas: Hmm… Not so helpful clue. Can you please give one more?
Robert: Yeah! Can you see the number on the house across the street?
Thomas: Yes! I can.
Robert: The sum of their ages equal that number.
Thomas: Sorry! I still could not determine their ages.
Robert: My oldest child has red hair.
Thomas: OH.. Oldest one? Finally I got it. I know age of each of your children.
What were the ages of Robert’s children and how did Thomas know?
Discussion and probable answer
This is a very good logical problem. To do it, first write down all the real possibilities that the number on that building might have been. Assuming integer ages one get get the following which equal 36 when multiplied:
|Age of 1st||Age of 2nd||Age of 3rd||Sum(HouseNo.)|
The biggest clue is that the Thomas DID NOT KNOW after having been told the sum equaled the number on the house. Why didn’t he know? The only reason would be that the number was 13, in which case there are two possible answers. For any other number, the answer is unique and the Thomas would have known after the second clue. So he asked for a third clue. The clue that the oldest had red hair is really just saying that there is an “oldest”, meaning that the older two are not twins. Hence, the answer is that the redhead is 9 years old, and the younger two are both 2 years old.
Source of The Puzzle: This puzzle is a modified form of a puzzle from Science Reporter Magazine, Hindi 1996 and I have changed the names from Ram and Shyam to Robert and Thomas to make this puzzle convenient to read.
- Just another way to Multiply (wpgaurav.wordpress.com)
Solve the equation
- The function has derivatives. Show that if and then we can find such that .
For , let where the sum ranges over all pairs of positive integer satisfying the indicated inequalities. Evaluate:
- This problem deals to elementary functional analysis and is taken from very old paper of Putnam Competitions.
has continuous second derivative and , for all .
are integers such that are all integers. Put and .
• Show that for , there are atmost such indices .
• Show that there are atmost lattice points on the curve .